Skip to main content

Twilight by Stephanie Meyer Twilight Saga #1 -- a review by Elleanore Vance

 

 


Welcome my Lovely Readers! You are in for a very very special column today. I put a lot of love into this one, and I hope it shows.

Let me take us all back to October 2005. I was a newly-wed and completely oblivious. I was hard-core into Harry Potter-land. With the release of Half-Blood Prince (on my wedding day) I couldn't have asked for more.  I didn't know that a new god had been born to my pantheon.  

Fast forward a few years and my hubby had joined a horror book club that offered him 3 hardcovers at ninety-nine cents apiece.  Now, I had become aware of this phenomenon going on the book world that had teenage girls and their mothers screaming at book releases the same way they would for a Generic Boy Band concert (no shame, just facts) and I felt I wasn't allowed to join them. So I ignored it. But then, Hubby, with this book club... y'all he didn't get anything for himself. He got the htree Twilight books that had been published at that point.

I love me some vampire stories from Anne Rice to Laurell K. Hamilton, but these weren't meant for me. I was certain i wouldn't be able to relate at all.  So I put  Twilight, New Moon, and Eclipse in a closet and did my best to forget about them. That is where they would stay for the next couple of years.  

Now, I know y'all are gonna say I'm insane, and maybe I am, but I swear  from time to time i heard them whisper to me from the darkness of that closet,  "Read Me!" I was doomed. I caved sometime in 2008.

I'm not trying to say that Stephanie Meyer is the best author ever,  but this book holds a special place in my heart.  Reading it in 2022 brought back such a feeling of nostalgia and so very much Dopamine.

I am not going to use this space to try to convert you from a hater to a Twihard,Ii am going to talk about what I love about this first book and why it resonated with me.  Why it still resonates with me today.  And what i saw differently this time around.  If you're a Twilight hater, a Stephanie Meyer hater, or you just don't want to go there, please feel free to skip the rest, I'm sure I'll catch you next time ☺️☺️

In the event you've spent the last decade and a half under a rock,  I'm going to give you a short synopsis. Bella Swan moves to Forks, Washington to live with her father so that her "flighty,  harebrained mother" can go on the road with her second husband, a minor league baseball player.  Her dad is chief of police Charlie Swan. Bella rekindles a friendship with the youngest child of Charlie's Bff, Jacob Black. Jacob is a Quillute and a resident of the nearby reservation.

In the Forks High School, Bella makes surface level friends with a group of teens. She is constantly rebuffing the advances of her male classmates, except Edward Cullen who seems reviled by her to an exaggerated extent.  According to Meyer, this is a retelling of Pride and Prejudice, spiced up with her version of vampire lore.

This was something that really hooked me as a long-time vampire reader. Meyer's vampire lore pulled out of thin air is unlike any other. I think it really rejuvenated the interest in the sub-genre. And by accident (maybe) Meyers made the toughest, hardest to kill vampires known to literature.  These vampires walk in the daylight,  are able to carry religious items,  cross running water,  are impervious to wooden stakes with skin like stone. They can be broken into pieces and burned, but then like a medieval european witch, the ashes must be scattered. You must admit its a novelty.  

In addition to the novelty factor,  I see a lot of myself in Bella. You see,  she, too was a parentified child.  We see evidence of this very early in the book:
 

How could I leave my loving, erratic,  harebrained mother to fend for herself? Of course she had Phil now, so the bills would get paid, there would be food in the refrigerator, gas in her car, and someone to call when she got lost, but still...

We get another example of this when Bella takes over Charlie's housekeeping:

 So I requested that I be assigned kitchen detail for the duration of my stay... I also found out that he had no food in the house.

All of this makes total sense later when Bella is asked her age.  Her reply:

My mom always says I was born thirty-five years old and that i get more middle aged every year.

The nail in the coffin of this is Bella's follow-up statement, further down the page, that "Someone had to be the adult."

Far from the helpless, hapless heroine many of the haters have made her out to be, Bella is loyal, super courageous and cool under pressure in a way some of us recognize from our childhoods. Really. She's just clumsy!

Bella and I also happen to be devout readers as well as people-pleasers. Our mothers were too young to know the harm they were causing, our fathers are emotionally distant,  but do their best to be loving and supportive. Doesn't everyone know by now that Charlie Doesn't Hover?


Of course when I initially read this book,  I don't know that I picked up on a lot of that, I just know that it tickled my brain. Somehow, I had found another safe place within the pages of a book.

Nearly twenty years later, I found myself overwhelmed not only by nostalgia for the story itself,  but the time in my life it represented.  As for what I see differently now,  Mike is creepy A. F. Right from go.  And the fact that a boy Bella has repeatedly told no shows up to her house to pick her up for the dance she's already at is just cringe.  

I admit that outside the context of this story Edward is a total stalker creeper dude, but he isn't the one that makes my skin crawl with his insistence.  That award goes to Mike Newton.  His whole thing just gets worse over the course of the series.  We'll go more into that another time.

Through this story,  I am able to have the fantasy of a  semi-functioning relationship with my own mother. And it transports me back to a time before my biggest personal losses.

Thanks to this book,  I have found so many people I truly vibe with.  

Twilight can do what I need fiction to do the most: gives me hope.  And Dopamine.  

Thanks so much for hanging out with me,  if you stayed.  I really hope you enjoyed this piece.  And if you skipped Twilight for whatever reason back in the day,  maybe it's time you gave it a go.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5

Comments