Skip to main content

Damia by Anne McCaffrey Tower and Hive book 2 Review by Elleanore Vance


So, I read a ton of sci-fi when I was a kid, before I started keeping track of what I was reading. A consequence of this is that for me, this book got lost to the sands of time. A few years ago grief sent me into a no-reading spiral, so when enough time had passed, I went back to basics and started reading authors totally un-associated with my lost loved one. That brought me back to one of my first loves, Anne McCaffrey.   When I read The Rowan a few months back, I had some tickles of familiarity. I hadn't read it before, but maybe I read something later in the series?? As Tower and Hive is a spin-off of McCaffrey's Pern saga, I could have. It was a very long time ago.

Then I picked up  "Damia" and the tickle became a klaxon.

At the beginning of this book we rewind the timeline a bit to allow us to focus on a character who is little more than a passing mention in The Rowan.  Afra Lyon ,who is practically an infant, is absolutely distraught that his favorite elder sister has been away, training with The Rowan. We see him grow up, and earn his place by The Rowan's side as her second. We know that Ridinger,  Earth Prime has hoped that Afra would mate The Rowan. Maybe Afra hoped that, too, but then Jeff Raven erupts onto the scene. We get to see "backstage" of the third act of The Rowan, through Afra's eyes.

The birth of The Rowan's first two children, the defeat of the invaders from deep space, The Rowan's formal marriage to Jeff Raven, and the complications she suffered with her third pregnancy, which became Damia.* I feel it is important here to note that Afra was asked and agreed to become a formal god-parent type designation (LP, for Loco Parentis) to all three Gwynn-Raven children.*

Afra seems content to be a bystander in the Gwynn-Raven family instead of beginning a family of his own. With the birth of Damia, our focus shifts to our title character. She is constantly left out of her siblings` games, and so is usually in trouble. She is lonely and just wanting to play. Afra has become something special to Damia's young self, finding her when she escapes the home unit, or daycare, and bringing her back home safely, when she accidentally launches herself in a cargo pod headed off-world. Damia is a constant frustration to her mother (a full time Prime in her own Tower), and Jeff is rarely home, so when she wants comfort, she turns to Afra. Until the cargo pod incident. Then she and her elder siblings are sent to live with their grandmother, to save them from the potential dangers of growing up in a space station. It also allowed them a wider range of playmates.

For the good it did, there was also trauma. Damia was removed from her emotional support human. We enjoy Damia's girlhood, playing, getting in trouble, dealing with bullies, welcoming a little brother who becomes her closest companion. Following the pattern of "The Rowan", we have a cradle to mating type story with some sci-fi spice, and interplanetary drama thrown in for flavor.

I wish I could share with you the joy of recognition I felt when The Rowan suggests Afra take a gift to Ridinger early in the book. A pure moment of clear remembrance, which instantly transported me to the spare bedroom in my grandfather's home when I was somewhere between fourteen and sixteen years old. This was the book that ignited my origami obsession. As much as I remembered, I had forgotten more. For that reason, I am leaving my review off here. If you don't want spoilers, stop here. Thanks!


⭐⭐⭐3/5


 Beware!! Triggers and spoilers ahead!

Damia's first sexual encounter may be problematic  for modern readers. The age gap between the couple is enough that many would call him a pedophile. My only rebuttal to this is that McCaffrey allows her characters to have agency. The way it is written is very much
not predatory. Damia decides the encounter will happen. The only circumstance that would make this encounter *ape, is the age difference.

Age gap aside, Damia permanently disables the Young man during the encounter because she doesn't know she needs to hold in her psychic-ness during physical intimacy. Her powers fried his brain like an egg and he will have to be cared for for the rest of his young life. And of course the whole situation gets Catholic Church-ed, because of course it did, her parents are the head of FT&T.

We get an  echo of this encounter with the ultimate relationship between Afra and Damia. Many of us in 2022 will have a hard time seeing beyond the childhood relationship the two have had, and the large age gap. I know I did, and I don't generally have a problem with an age gap couple. I mean.... he's her GODFATHER! He rocked her to sleep as an infant! And now they're gonna make babies! Its creepy!

Lastly, I want to warn anyone who has had a traumatic brain injury. We get a scene where a character is hit in the head with a rock.


All of this info was considered in my rating. Damia is definitely a book of its time.

Comments